Original topic:

"CLOSE ALL" BUTTON!!!!

(Topic created on: 11-10-2021 10:08 AM)
8555 Views
garageninja
Active Level 3
Options
Galaxy S
(DeEAR SAMSUNG and Community Members,)

HELLO GOOD AFTERNOON!
WHY IS IT THAT THE "CLOSE ALL" BUTTON ON THE MULTI TASK SCREEN IS SO PROMINENT AND IN THE CENTER OF THE SCREEN??

This is a MAJOR design flaw as a person could EASILY accidentally press it by even the palm of their hands. The same provisions taken to prevent accidentally answering or rejecting a phone call MUST be taken to prevent accidentally pressing the "Close All" button! I've written several times regarding this and the first time I got a generic irrelevant answer. PLEASE someone read this and do what is necessary to address this issue.
What do people mainly do on phones?
They "use apps". So how could their be a button that could potentially accidentally cross ALL apps! 

I'm by no means an expert at designing phone interfaces, but here are my suggestions:

Option i.
Add a thing that the user has to slide just as when answering a phone call.

Option ii.
Make the button less prominent or centrally located

Option iii.
HIDE THE BUTTON WITHIN A NESTED MENU even in Settings --> Apps --> Close All Open Apps
and remove it from the multitasking screen entirely.

You have done EXCELLENT work on every other aspect of the phone and I know that little things like this can be easily overlooked on such big project. This is why I'm actually taking time out of my busy day to bring this to your attention.


PS:
and consider the following scenario: a person has 20 IMPORTANT windows open, most having entered data. Then they are holding there phone so that the left thumb is at the bottom left of the screen, as the right thumb is tapping on the content of the screen the left thumb accidentally slides to press the 3 bars opening the multitasking screen, then the right thumb which was in the act of pressing presses instead the "Close All" button and closes everything, INCLUDING the app you were currently working on. This ACTUALLY HAPPENED. 

This is a major design flaw!
34 Comments
RedDogRabbit
Expert Level 5
Galaxy S

You can actually "lock" or "Keep Open" 3 apps.

The "Close All" button seems fine where it is to me. 

Screenshot_20231226_122423_One UI Home.jpg

0 Likes
ukanuk
Beginner Level 2
Galaxy S

Ugh, bugs me too. I rarely hit it, but when I accidentally do it's quite annoying. Would very much like an option to add an "Are you sure" popup or move it into the three-dot menu.

adririn8
Beginner Level 2
Galaxy S

Agreed. 2024 here and I've been a samsung user since S7 and it *** drives me nuts year after year. I move to switch apps and instead accidentally graze the *** "close all apps" button and bam! Now I don't even have any apps left to swap between. Gotta go back to reopening like 16 *** apps.

 

Such an annoying UI issue that could just be easily fixed if they cared to listen.

PeterETposts
Beginner Level 2
Galaxy S
I never use the "close all" accept accidentally. There should be an option to remove it.
0 Likes
RedDogRabbit
Expert Level 5
Galaxy S

I've never accidentally used the Close All button..

It's quite useful & really very out of the way. 

Screenshot_20240822_125758_One UI Home.jpg

0 Likes