Original topic:

Who prefers smart select over AI select

(Topic created on: 03-03-2025 12:59 AM)
240 Views
qwer123
Active Level 6
Options
Galaxy S
Frankly, the AI text selection feature is problematic. For instance, when selecting text, it sometimes unnecessarily crops the content instead of allowing selection of the text and surrounding elements, or an entire paragraph for image sharing. This is undesirable because sharing often requires contextual elements, but the AI's forced text selection prevents resizing and necessitates restarting from scratch.

This Quran page exemplifies a usability issue. My intention was to share a portion as an image, but the AI selection tool interfered, necessitating a full screenshot. I needed to highlight or underline specific text without cropping, yet the AI consistently selected text regardless of my selection. Conversely, the One UI 5 and 6 smart select functionality allowed for text selection or detection, offering user choice. The AI, however, assumes text selection, which is undesirable when the goal is annotation or similar actions rather than text cropping.

The current AI selection functionality represents a step backward and is superfluous; reverting to the non-AI version, which effectively detects text and allows for straightforward copying, would be preferable. AI does not always accurately interpret user intent. For instance, image cropping, while seemingly straightforward in its objective of subject selection, presents complexities that the AI struggles to manage effectively.
image


image

As illustrated in the second image, the AI is forcibly selecting text, which is undesirable even with intentional user selection. Due to a language barrier, the selection was incomplete, failing to capture the intended portion for quick sharing with highlighting or circling. Therefore, please rectify this AI selection interference. Where this T button give us the ability to deselect the T and let us to it the old classic smart select way. Like I stated I want to select only a small portion no the enite line or page and with AI getting in the way it thinks it knows and knowing AI can't always get your preference right their should atleast be an opition to resize to personal preferences. 

2 Comments
Helenna
Moderator
Moderator
Options
Galaxy S

Hi qwer123,

Thank you for your detailed feedback regarding the AI text selection feature. We understand your frustration and appreciate you taking the time to share your experience.

The AI-driven selection is designed to enhance usability by detecting and selecting text efficiently. We will consider this as a valuable feedback and will share with our development team.

We continuously strive to improve the user experience, and user insights like yours play a crucial role in shaping future updates. 

qwer123
Active Level 6
Galaxy S
The cropping and resizing functionality should allow for adjustable selection areas. Previously, text was deducted, but the full text selection wasn't enforced. For example, annotating and sharing a screenshot portion is hindered by the forced text selection; image sharing, with or without text, shouldn't be restricted. SmartSelect's core functionality was to facilitate the sharing or saving of specific screen sections without requiring screenshots and subsequent editing. However, the current text extraction method necessitates reverting to the traditional screenshot and editing workflow.